Please write and send praise, critique, interesting links or random musings to

Thursday, March 4, 2010

The Dis-ingenuousness of Bart Stupak

March 4th, 2010

As was reported in today's Huffington Post, Rep. Bart Stupak (D-Mich) is threatening to torpedo the Health Care Reform bill if it fails to contain his particular language preventing the use of public funds for abortion procedures. If there were not already a law specifically preventing that very activity, this could be seen as a legitimate position.  

Passed in 1976 and renewed annually, The Hyde Amendment prohibits the use of any taxpayer funds in paying for an abortion accept in the case of a pregnancy which endangers the life of the expectant mother. Whether one agrees with this standing legislation is immaterial to the debate at hand. Now along comes The Stupak-Pitts amendment named for the Senator from Michigan and his ally from the so-called "Family," Rep. Joseph R. Pitts (R-Pa).

For a particularly good piece on the "Family," click here.

As described in the New York Times, "The amendment prevents women who receive federal insurance subsidies from buying abortion coverage — but critics assert it could cause women who buy their own insurance difficulty in obtaining coverage." 

It is worth noting that Rep. Stupak has a somewhat checkered history with regards to other issues. He has been right a lot of the time but he could not be more wrong in this instance. One has to wonder if this stridency is the price for continued membership in the "Family."

No comments:

Post a Comment